Turkey recalls envoy in ‘genocide’ row

Armenian commemoration in Istanbul, 24 Apr 16Image copyright

Image caption

Persecuted Armenian intellectuals were remembered at a ceremony in Istanbul in April

Turkey has recalled its envoy to Germany in protest against German MPs declaring the 1915 massacre of Armenians during WWI as “genocide”.

Turkey called the vote “an example of ignorance and disrespect”.

Armenians say up to 1.5 million of their people died in the atrocities of 1915. Turkey says the toll was much lower and rejects the term “genocide”.

The vote heightens German-Turkish tensions at a time when Turkey’s help is needed to control migrant arrivals.

The Turkish President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, said the resolution would seriously affect relations with Germany, and that the government would consider further measures in response to the vote.

QA: Armenian genocide dispute

Image copyright

Image caption

Turkish ultra-nationalists protested against the vote outside the German Consulate in Istanbul on Thursday

The Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu tweeted: “The way to close the dark pages in your own history is not by besmirching the history of other countries with irresponsible and groundless parliamentary decisions,” a clear reference to Germany’s Nazi past.

But the German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier called for calm.

“As expected, Turkey has reacted, and I hope that we will succeed in the next days and weeks to avoid any overreaction,” he told journalists during a visit to Buenos Aires.

Armed riot police were deployed outside the German consulate in Istanbul, near Taksim square, where a protest against the vote was taking place.

In other reaction:

  • Turkey’s Prime Minister Binali Yildirim blamed a “racist Armenian lobby” for the resolution
  • Armenia’s Foreign Minister Edward Nalbandian said it was a “valuable contribution” to the “international recognition and condemnation of the Armenian genocide”
  • German Chancellor Angela Merkel said: “There is a lot that binds Germany to Turkey and even if we have a difference of opinion on an individual matter, the breadth of our links, our friendship, our strategic ties, is great”

Armenian ‘genocide’ vote ignites press

Image copyright

Image caption

Some Armenian community leaders in Germany attended the Bundestag debate

Turkey denies that there was a systematic campaign to slaughter Armenians as an ethnic group during World War One. It also points out that many Turkish civilians died in the turmoil during the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Mrs Merkel was not in the Bundestag (lower house) for the vote. Her Christian Democrats (CDU), their coalition partners the Social Democrats (SPD) and the Greens all supported the resolution, and the vote in favour was overwhelming, with only one vote against and one abstention.

The resolution uses the word “genocide” in the headline and text. It also says Germany, at the time an ally of the Ottomans, bears some guilt for doing nothing to stop the killings.

Question of German guilt – Damien McGuinness, BBC News, Berlin

Image copyright

Image caption

Pro-Turkish protesters demonstrated against the resolution in Berlin on Wednesday

For many German politicians, this vote was about dealing with not just Turkey’s difficult 20th Century history, but also Germany’s.

Many of the speeches in parliament focused on German responsibility in the 1915 killings. At the time, the German empire was a military ally of the Ottomans, and is accused of knowing about the massacres and not doing anything to prevent them. So for many Germans this resolution is about facing up to German historical guilt – something modern Germany is founded upon.

More than 20 nations, including France and Russia, as well as the European Parliament, have already recognised the 1915 massacre as a genocide.

But Thursday’s vote comes at a particularly bad time.

The big question is what this all means for Europe’s attempts to solve the migrant crisis.

Diplomatic relations may be strained. But the hope in Berlin is that tensions don’t scupper the EU’s new refugee deal with Turkey.

Under a deal struck in March, Turkey agreed to take back migrants, including Syrians, arriving on Greek islands, in return for EU aid and a pledge to give Turks visa-free travel to most of Europe.

Germany accepted 1.1 million migrants last year, by far the highest influx in the EU.

German-Turkish relations were also strained this year by the case of comedian Jan Boehmermann, whose obscene poem about Mr Erdogan prompted a criminal complaint from the Turkish leader.

Last month a court in Hamburg ruled that Boehmermann’s poem was satire, but banned him from repeating the sexual references in it, deeming them unacceptable.

Germany plans to repeal a clause in the constitution prohibiting insults that target foreign leaders – the clause invoked by Turkey in the complaint.

Armenian genocide dispute

Image copyright

Image caption

Arguments have raged for decades about the Armenian deaths in 1915-16

  • Hundreds of thousands of Christian Armenians died in 1915 at the hands of the Ottoman Turks, whose empire was disintegrating
  • Many of the victims were civilians deported to barren desert regions where they died of starvation and thirst. Thousands also died in massacres
  • Armenia says up to 1.5 million people were killed. Turkey says the number of deaths was much smaller
  • Most non-Turkish scholars of the events regard them as genocide – as do more than 20 states including France, Germany and Russia, and some international bodies such as the European Parliament
  • Turkey rejects the term “genocide”, maintaining that many of the dead were killed in clashes during World War One, and that many ethnic Turks also suffered in the conflict

Armenian tragedy still raw in Turkey

comments powered by Disqus