Why Books and Movies Are Better the Second Time | Odd Onion

Why Books and Movies Are Better the Second Time

February 17, 2012
By

New research reveals why people like to reread books, re-watch movies and generally repeat the same experiences over and over again. It’s not addictive or ritualistic behavior, but rather a conscious effort to probe deeper layers of significance in the revisited material, while also reflecting on one’s own growth through the lens of the familiar book, movie or place.

Cristel Russell, a consumer behavior researcher at American University, and her colleagues interviewed 23 people to identify the underlying reasons for what they call “re-consumption.” As detailed in a forthcoming paper in the Journal of Consumer Research, the researchers found that re-consumption is not merely a nostalgic attempt to retrieve the past, but rather an active search for new meaning, and one that has great emotional value.

“Because re-experiencing offers a way to look at oneself through the same lens but with different eyes, it offers many therapeutic benefits,” Russell wrote in an email. “So long as one is actively conscious of the re-experience (and it’s not a passive, uncontrollable addiction), it can offer many self-reflexive opportunities.”

For example, one study participant was a church minister who regularly rereads the Bible. He said he sometimes interprets familiar passages differently and therefore has to amend the views he might have expressed publicly. “He saw this as a sign of growth,” Russell told Life’s Little Mysteries. [6 Fun Ways to Sharpen Your Memory]

The authors said their finding confirmed an assertion of the German philosopher Martin Heidegger, who in 1953 argued that repetition enables one to achieve an understanding of one’s personal past. More importantly, re-consuming causes the contrasts between our past and present selves to become manifest. We recall how we interpreted words or footage in the past, and reflect on the differences with our current interpretation. 

Re-consumption also can be deeply therapeutic. “Psychotherapists view the repetition of an experience as useful to purge that experience of its emotional excesses, a psychoanalytical concept called abreaction,” the study authors explain. “The re-experience allows one to become conscious of repressed or suppressed traumatic events. It has led the way to abreaction therapy, where patients are helped to re-enact the experience in a controlled environment  – for instance, to resolve post–traumatic stress disorder, characterized by the persistent re-experience of a traumatic event.”

For example, a study participant named Lynette read a book, “The Bridges of Madison County,” for abreaction. She explained that there are “just times when I’m feeling a bit low for some reason; I need to read that book, have a real good cry, and get it all out of my system  –  and, I don’t know, it just does it for me.”

In short, the researchers explained, the book allows her to purge an excess of sadness.

Russell said the new findings have profound implications for marketing. “Marketers are always trying to keep experiences fresh and new. We show that even old experiences can be perceived as offering new perspectives,” she wrote. “Also, many industries are in the business of re-launching, or creating new versions of this or that (movies made from stories in a book, re-releases of old classics, etc.), so we show them the ways in which consumers may respond to these re-experiences.”

The study has psychological implications, too, she said. Instead of feeling awkward or unusual about rereading the same books, re-watching films or revisiting the same places, the study shows that in fact re-consuming is therapeutic and should be encouraged. “In the age of progress and always pushing newness and differences, it seems that we forget that it’s okay to redo.”

Follow Natalie Wolchover on Twitter @nattyover. Follow Life’s Little Mysteries on Twitter @llmysteries, then join us on Facebook.

Related posts:

  1. Gingrich praised FDR, New Deal in ’95, ’06 books (Daily Caller) In two books, the man who calls President Barack Obama a “food-stamp president” praised the man whose administration created the first food stamp program. Snubbing 16 other presidents including Ronald Reagan, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich called Franklin D. Roosevelt “probably the greatest president of the twentieth century” in his...
  2. 5 NC-17 movies worth seeing (AP) NEW YORK – Is NC-17 really the kiss of death? Will the merest flash of naked flesh or the softest moan from hot, sweaty bods doom a film to celluloid purgatory? Granted, only one movie with the adults-only marker (no one under 17 admitted) has become a box-office hit (“Showgirls”),...
  3. 5 movies for which to be thankful (AP) LOS ANGELES – It’s Thanksgiving this week, a time to reflect on the people and things for which we’re grateful. Since I love movies, I thought it would be a good time to choose five for which I’m thankful. These are the cinematic equivalent of comfort food, ones I can...
  4. 5 great movies about pregnancy (AP) LOS ANGELES – This is not a spoiler: Bella has Edward’s baby in “The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn — Part 1,” a human-vampire hybrid that eats her up from the inside and threatens her very life. For most mortals, having a baby isn’t that melodramatic. But a lot of movies...
  5. Fandango debuts mobile phone tickets for movies (omg!) LOS ANGELES (AP) — Online ticket seller Fandango said Thursday that customers heading to see movies on more than 1,000 screens owned by Regal Entertainment Corp. no longer have to print out tickets — as long as they have a cellphone with a screen. Fangango will now send movie-goers a...